Although not quite good enough to make me cry, these cherry pie cookies are surprisingly tasty. Some of you might remember that I'm jaded when it comes to Trader Joe's cookies—crunchy cookies in particular—having tried well upwards of one hundred different varieties over the past decade and a half. But I gotta tell ya, these get a solid thumbs up from both the beautiful wifey and me.
Trader Joe's Cherry Pie Cookies aren't soft per se, but they're so crumbly that they don't put up a fight at all when you eat them. I mean, they're messy, but I can live with that. The dried bing cherries are a nice touch, although the cookies would be a lot stronger if there were way more of them. The crunchy cherry candy things add a bit of extra cherry flavor and a nice smattering of color to the appearance. The white chocolate chips are just perfect for adding a bit of extra sweetness to the taste and softness to the bite. The bread part is a little buttery like a nice homemade pie crust. According to Sonia, the cookies pair perfectly with a cup of hot coffee.
We didn't try serving them with anything fancy, but I could see these working pretty well alongside a scoop of vanilla ice cream, maybe with a little cherry pie filling or whipped cream on top if you're feeling ambitious. You could probably even warm them up just a touch to soften the white chocolate and make them taste a little more like an actual slice of cherry pie. A cup of hot chocolate wouldn't hurt, either. Or a glass of milk. Or maybe just eat them straight out of the container like we did. No judgment here.
We plowed through the tub much faster than I imagined we would. Maybe we're just craving a bit of extra comfort food these days. Maybe we feel bad about being so grumpy when we review Trader Joe's cookies usually. I dunno. Mark us both down for eight out of ten stars a piece for Trader Joe's Cherry Pie Cookies. $4.49 for the 9 oz tub. Kosher. Would buy again.
Bottom line: 8 out of 10.


















































