Trader Joe's Old Fashioned

Neither Sonia nor I had ever tried an Old Fashioned prior to picking up this product. Sonia, in particular, had always wanted to try one. The drink originated in the late 19th century, with bar patrons requesting that drinks be prepared "the old fashioned way."

I'm not sure how they prepared drinks "the new way" by 1880s standards, but folks were apparently craving nothing but whiskey, bitters, sugar, and water. That's basically what we have here. It's a mixed drink, but it's still nice and simple.

We've got a quality American bourbon, lightly buttery and sweet, balanced out by orange bitters in the background. On ice, with an orange slice and maybe a cherry or two, the drink is still whiskey forward, but it's not as harsh as drinking straight liquor. It has all the niceties of a fancy cocktail while still packing a punch in the spirits department.

The 750 mL bottle is 35% alcohol by volume, and it's got some classy, timeless artwork on the label. Sonia's a graphic designer, and she absolutely loves the packaging on this product. It's quite convenient having everything pre-mixed and ready to pour.

At $19.99 for the fifth, it's a pretty decent bargain, too. We'd both buy again. Eight out of ten stars from me for Trader Joe's Old Fashioned. Sonia will go with eight and a half out of ten.

Bottom line: 8.25 out of 10.